This store requires javascript to be enabled for some features to work correctly.

Valentine's 2024 :: Gift Guide

Valentine's 2024 :: Gift Guide

| Shane Dennehey

Valentine's Day is Coming 🥰 The weeks leading up to Valentine's are some of our busiest and most enjoyable of the year! Our little heartmaking shop is running at full capacity, making treasures for you. We're working hard so you can share your heart with someone you love this Valentine's Day!

Most of these favorites are in stock and ready to ship 🚚 however, some are a part of our handmade-to-order collection—we make these items in small batches with pre-order deadlines. The made-to-order deadline for Valentine's delivery is Thursday, January 25. See each description below to see specific Valentine's Day shipping cutoff dates.

💘 Here's A List of our Most Valentinesy Gifts 💘

1 365 Love Notes In Stock
365 Love Notes

Make Every Day Valentine's Day! These little inspirational cards are a daily dose of love, affirmation, and truth—every card contains a heartfelt message about love. We designed them to be little daily prompts to center your heart.

We lovingly curated a collection of quotes, verses, and lyrics from antiquity that is sure to keep your heart full every day this year!

Every Set of Love Notes includes 365 cards printed on natural white archival card stock and a desk stand made with reclaimed wood. As a special treat, every set includes a free pair of our super-popular wooden hearts, all in a gift-worthy box! 

The deadline for Valentine's delivery of In-Stock Items is Monday, February 5

 ❤️🤍 Say 'I Love You' every day with 365 Love Notes!

2 Art Prints In Stock
Keys To My Heart Art Print

Show Your Walls Some Love With Heart Art Prints! Our art collection grew leaps and bounds last year, and our hearts skip a beat every time we send another print out into the world 💌

The pictured Keys To My Heart Art Print is the most loved piece of art so far. Other favorites are; New Song In My HeartLove Lives Here, and all of the Heart Grid Art Prints.

The deadline for Valentine's delivery of In-Stock Items is Monday, February 5

😍 Give the gift of beauty with our heart art collection!

 3 State Plate Heart Art Made to Order
State Plate Heart Art

States Of Love These rustic and charming heart-shaped state plates are the perfect way to express your love! Made using license plates from all around the USA. Cut and fastened by hand in Keller, Texas. Every reused plate is unique, so each work of art is one-of-a-kind.

The made-to-order deadline for Valentine's delivery is Thursday, January 25

👩🏻‍❤️‍👨🏻 My wife, Bonnie gave me one of these last year since I grew up in Iowa, and she's always been a Texan. Such a great gift! 

4 Mystery Boxes In Stock
Mystery Boxes

A Heart Filled With Hearts We filled heart-shaped boxes with an adorable assortment of our handmade wooden hearts. Every single box is filled to capacity with a super cute and top secret 🤫 variety of hearts that our team lovingly curated and packaged just for you ❤️

Every Mystery Box contains over $200.00 worth of handmade wooden hearts for less than half price—and we’re giving you the heart-shaped box for free! We generously filled these giftable boxes with an eclectic assortment of beautifully handcrafted wooden hearts!

The deadline for Valentine's delivery of In-Stock Items is Monday, February 5

🙋‍♀️ Who wants to be surprised with love this Valentine's Day!?

5 Candy Hearts In StockCandy Hearts

Cutesy Nostalgia We made this boxed set of wooden hearts to resemble the ones we exchanged every Valentine's day in elementary school—those brightly colored candy hearts inscribed with cutesy love notes. 

Each Candy Heart Boxed Set Includes 12 Wooden Hearts
You'll get a dozen hand-dyed solid maple hearts engraved with 12 classic love messages. Delivered in a custom-made box that perfectly showcases the hearts.

The deadline for Valentine's delivery of In-Stock Items is Monday, February 5

💙❤️🧡💛💚 We designed this boxed set to be extra giftable—a fun and nostalgic way to share your heart!


Share Your Heart With The Small Things, Too 🥰
We have so many little lovelies to sweep your Valentine off their feet!
Here are a few of our favorites:

 Heartwork Stickers
 Heartwork Pins
• Wooden Magnet Hearts

 LOL Necklaces
 Imperfect Heart Charms


We hope this list inspires you to share your ❤ this Valentine's Day! 
If you still haven’t found the perfect gift for your Valentine, message or call us, and we’ll help!

We’re always willing to customize your order or select the perfect piece.
If you have a special request, we can help; just let us know.


 Download our App • Early Access + 15% Off!
 Subscribe to the Email List • Stay informed + Special discounts
✅ Follow us on Social Media • Facebook + Instagram



  • Posted by Cindy Wood on

    How much is the candy gift heart set of 12?

  • Posted by Robyn on

    I have purchased heats from you in the past. I love them. I need 20 they can be miscellaneous. When I look at the website it states if you purchase xxx amount 20% or something off for buying more. I don’t see that reflected in the price when I checkout. Help!

Leave a comment