This store requires javascript to be enabled for some features to work correctly.

Free Shipping $72+ | Free Returns | Handmade With 🤍

2023 dennehey design christmas gift guide with hearts

Christmas 2023 :: Gifts For You

| Shane Dennehey

Christmas Shipping Update:

In-Stock Items are guaranteed to ship when ordered on or before December 15, 2023. Shop the collection here: In-Stock and ready to ship!

Made-to-Order and Pre-Order Items may not arrive until after Christmas.

It’s already that “most wonderful” time of the year 🎄 and we hope your holiday season is off to a fantastic start! We know life gets busy this time of year, so we made you a list of our most giftable items. These are the top five most-loved gifts in our catalog this year! 

Many of these favorites are in stock and ready to ship 🚚 however, some are a part of our handmade-to-order collection—we make these items in small batches with pre-order deadlines. The final preorder deadline for Christmas delivery is Tuesday, November 28. See each product description below to see specific Christmas shipping cutoff dates.

1 The Original Promise Cross In Stock

The Promise Cross

The Promise Cross has been one of our customer favorites ever since its initial launch this spring. Our neighbor and fellow artisan, Patrick Neuwirth, makes these crosses to portray the crucifixion of Jesus Christ; the heart delicately balanced in the middle of the cross symbolizes God’s love, the gift of his Son, and the incredible offering that He gave to us through His promise in John 3:16 that says, “whoever believes in Him shall not perish but have eternal life.”

✝️ Every cross is a unique piece of art—a gift that will surely be cherished for a lifetime!

2 Hearts From The Holy Land In Stock

Olive Wood Hearts From The Holy Land

These beautifully handcrafted hearts are extraordinary creations! Local artisans handcraft each heart in the heart of ancient Israel—Bethlehem and Jerusalem—the Holy Land of the Bible. They make these stunning hearts from remnant olive wood branches that have fallen from trees over 1,000 years old. The trees are unharmed and live to bear fruit (and branches) for years to come!

🤎 Sold in sets of three, Holy Land hearts need to be under every Christmas tree!

 3 365 Card Sets In Stock

365 Heart Cards

We made three sets of 365 cards this year! Love Notes, Imperfect Cards, and Heartwork Cards. All of them have been super popular! The latest of the three—Heartwork Cards—is the crowd favorite, but each card set is a great choice, depending on who is on your list. We designed these card sets to encourage, inspire, and evoke love in the hearts of whoever sees them! 

🗓️ 365 cards are gifts your loved ones will appreciate every day of the coming year! 

4 Reclaimed Wooden Letters Preorder

May not arrive until after Christmas

Handmade Wooden Letters

Our wooden letters, numbers, and symbols have been a favorite gift for years! They are fantastic personalized gifts. We handcraft each letter to order using reclaimed piano wood, making each character uniquely beautiful! We already have many letters in our production queue, so time is running out—order on or before Tuesday, November 28, to ensure delivery by Christmas Day.

🔠 Our Reclaimed Wooden Letters are great personalized gifts for anyone you know with a letter in their name!

5 Christmas Piano Wood Stars Preorder

May not arrive until after Christmas

Christmas Stars Made With Piano Wood

We made five unique custom-engraved Christmas Stars out of reclaimed piano wood last year, and they sold immediately! Since then, we’ve made several more of each style in small batches and plan to make one last batch before this Christmas. Order on or before Tuesday, November 28, for yours to be in our final run of 2023 and to ensure delivery by Christmas Day!

⭐️ These custom-crafted stars are the perfect gift for the musician you love most!


Stocking Stuff 🎅
We have so many little treasures to stuff those stockings with!
Here are a few of our favorites:
Handmade Christmas Ornaments
• Wooden Magnet Hearts

Thin Pocket Crosses
Handmade Small Stars
Reclaimed Little Letters
LOL Necklaces
Imperfect Heart Charms
Heartwork Stickers
Heartwork Pins


We hope this list inspires you to share your ❤ this Christmas! 
If you still haven’t found the perfect gift, message or call us, and we’ll help you find the right gift for your loved ones!

We’re always willing to customize your order or select the perfect piece.
If you have a special request, we can help; just let us know.


Our Limited Christmas Collection Is Here

❤️ Christmas Colors :: Warm & Cozy
💙 Christmas Colors :: Frosty Feels
🎄 Christmas Engraved Hearts
💚 Christmas Heartstrings
💬 Christmas Inspired Word Hearts 
✂️ Christmas Fabric Hearts



Download our App • Early Access + 15% Off!
Subscribe to the Email List • Stay informed + Special discounts
✅ Follow us on Social Media • Facebook + Instagram


  • Posted by Sarah on

    Interested in your products. Christmas shopping.

  • Posted by Jamie on


Leave a comment