This store requires javascript to be enabled for some features to work correctly.

Valentine's Gift Guide :: 2025

Valentine's Gift Guide :: 2025

| Shane Dennehey

Valentine's Day is Coming 🥰 The weeks leading up to Valentine's are some of our busiest and most enjoyable of the year! Our little heartmaking shop is running at full capacity, making treasures for you. We're working hard so you can share your heart with someone you love this Valentine's Day! 

We reviewed our sales from the last year and feedback from our customers to select our top five gifts for this Valentine's Day. Most of these favorites are in stock and ready to ship 🚚 however, some are part of our handmade-to-order collection—we make these items in small batches with pre-order deadlines. The made-to-order deadline for Valentine's delivery is Thursday, January 23. See each description below for specific Valentine's Day shipping cutoff dates.

💘 Here's A List of our Top Five Most Valentinesy Gifts 💘

5. State Plate Heart Art — Made-to-Order

States Of Love These rustic and charming heart-shaped state plates are the perfect way to express your love! Made using license plates from all around the USA. Cut and fastened by hand in Keller, Texas. Every reused plate is unique, so each work of art is one-of-a-kind.

The made-to-order deadline for Valentine's delivery is Thursday, January 23

👩🏻‍❤️‍👨🏻 My wife, Bonnie gave me one of these last year since I grew up in Iowa, and she's always been a Texan. Such a great gift! 

4. Rococo Hearts — In Stock

These flamboyant little hearts are inspired by the carvings found on the piano wood we reclaim. We recreated several beautifully curvy patterns and embellished these hearts with contoured rococo forms. Each heart is engraved, hand-painted, shaped, and finished by hand. They are available in sets of six or twelve.

Order on or before Thursday, February 6 to get it for Valentine's Day.

These beautiful hearts are fantastic one-of-a-kind gifts to express your love!

3. Promise Cross Necklace — Preorder

These stunning sterling silver pendant necklaces are inspired by The Promise Cross—a simple yet powerful symbol of the crucifixion of Jesus Christ. This timeless design represents the fulfillment of God's eternal promise of love, as described in John 3:16: "For God so loved the world that He gave His one and only Son, that whoever believes in Him shall not perish but have eternal life."

Preorder on or before Thursday, January 23 to get it for Valentine's Day.

These necklaces are fantastic, meaningful gifts that will be cherished forever!

2. Connected Hearts From The Holy Land— In Stock

Two Intertwined Hearts Tell the Story of God’s Inseparable Love
These Connected Olive Wood Hearts From The Holy Land are tangible reminders that God’s love will last forever. The bonds of love He establishes here on earth will not be broken. Our hearts are forever linked to His.

These hand-carved pairs of hearts are made in the very place where our creator walked among us by woodworking artisans in Bethlehem and Jerusalem. Connect with the land of our creator in a new way with these olive wood heart sets. 

Order on or before Thursday, February 6 to get it for Valentine's Day.

Share God's Love with others by giving these beautiful hearts. They are meaningful gifts for those God has linked with your heart. 

1. 365 Love Notes — In Stock

Love is the answer quote

Make Every Day Valentine's Day! These little inspirational cards are a daily dose of love, affirmation, and truth—every card contains a heartfelt message about love. We designed them to be little daily prompts to center your heart.

We lovingly curated a collection of quotes, verses, and lyrics from antiquity that is sure to keep your heart full every day this year!

Every Set of Love Notes includes 365 cards printed on natural white archival card stock and a desk stand made with reclaimed wood. As a special treat, every set includes a free pair of our super-popular wooden hearts, all in a gift-worthy box! 

Order on or before Thursday, February 6 to get it for Valentine's Day.

 ❤️🤍 Say 'I Love You' every day with 365 Love Notes!


---

Share Your Heart With The Small Things, Too 🥰
We have so many little lovelies to sweep your Valentine off their feet!
Here are a few of our favorites:

 Heartwork Stickers
 Heartwork Pins
• Wooden Magnet Hearts

 LOL Necklaces
 Imperfect Heart Charms

----------

We hope this list inspires you to share your ❤ this Valentine's Day! 
If you still haven’t found the perfect gift for your Valentine, message or call us, and we’ll help!

We’re always willing to customize your order or select the perfect piece.
If you have a special request, we can help; just let us know.

Leave a comment